Monday, June 20, 2011

There are dissenting opinions on EVERY topic

[ON SEPTEMBER 18, 2011, SOMEONE PURPORTING TO BE L HOON, THE COPYRIGHT HOLDER OF THE QUOTED PAGES IN PHRENOLOGY.ORG, POSTED A COMMENT STATING THAT I HAD MADE A COPYRIGHT VIOLATION. WHILE I BELIEVE THAT THE QUOTES FALL UNDER FAIR USE, I HAVE REMOVED ALL QUOTES FROM THIS POST PER THE REQUEST OF THE COPYRIGHT HOLDER.]

I have a fake passport, acquired during my trip to France last year. Actually, it's a demonstration of passport printing technology from the parent company of my employer, and is clearly marked as a fake passport. (Too bad - the passport date of birth is younger than my true date of birth.) Every page has a statement along the lines of "THIS IS NOT A PASSPORT."

The opening page also has a statement, below the word "Phrenology." On this page, the statement reads "THIS IS NOT A SCIENCE."

Tell that to the folks at phrenology.org, a page that aims "to advocate a positive approach to scientific Phrenology."

Let's allow them to make their case:

[QUOTE REMOVED AT THE REQUEST OF THE COPYRIGHT HOLDER.]


So who is to blame for the low opinion of phrenology today? Sigmund Freud. Oh, and Adolf Hitler.

[QUOTE REMOVED AT THE REQUEST OF THE COPYRIGHT HOLDER.]

But these criticisms didn't start in the 20th century. They started with Napoleon Bonaparte:

[QUOTE REMOVED AT THE REQUEST OF THE COPYRIGHT HOLDER.]

Why is a discussion of phrenology relevant to a business blog? Because it illustrates that when you are creating a business plan, or a marketing campaign, you cannot necessarily make assumptions in the macro sense. Perhaps someday my company will give a fake passport to a dedicated phrenologist and offend him or her. Perhaps some day your company will contact a MySpace user and be surprised to learn that the user is a rich white male who hates music. Or perhaps a progressive American will be dismayed to be called "a stupid fascist cowboy American, just like Bush and Obama."

If you don't understand your customers, you don't understand your customers.
blog comments powered by Disqus