Sunday, December 4, 2011

How will your marketing materials be misused in an unat-tract-ive fashion?

A rare Sunday post, for reasons that will become obvious.

Many businesses and organizations produce marketing materials to hand out to clients. In many cases these items are not necessarily controversial in and of themselves, but if they are distributed under certain circumstances, they can become controversial. For example, funeral homes apologize in advance if their marketing materials happen to be received by someone who has just lost a loved one.

Religious organizations often hand out brief marketing messages called tracts. In a sense, they're the Twitter version of a theological discourse, carrying a brief message that closes with something that salespeople refer to as a "call to action." In the case of a Christian tract, that "call to action" is to accept Jesus into your life.

Of course, you need to get the person to look at your marketing material in the first place. Thus, tracts, like any other piece of marketing fluff, are often designed to attract the eye.

And in American culture, one sure-fire way to attract the eye is to design a tract that looks like money. If you're involved in handing out tracts, money tracts can become an important part of your tract ministry.

Of course, there are some legalities to be observed:

For money tracts to be legal to hand out, they need to be no more than 75
percent of the size of a regular dollar bill.


But they certainly can attract attention:

I have been starting out with Giant Money lately in the grocery stores, etc. and people are going crazy! Yesterday I went to this computer store and to my surprise, they were training a new set of employees for a new store they are opening. Wow! I gave away 25 of them. I started at the service desk and asked if they had change for this big money. They all laugh and of course, reached out to get one (it's as if it had a magnet on it)….Managers also ran over to my check out line--they were thrilled to receive big money…people go nuts over it no matter what age they are. They tell me that I made their day and most often say they are going to hang it on their wall. Of course, I must tell them that there is a cool message on it to read during their break so that they won't hang it on their wall before they read it.

It's all right and fine if it's given out under these circumstances. But someone used the fake money in an inappropriate fashion, making it look like real money. As a tip. For a waiter or waitress.

This actually happened. A restaurant worker saw a $10 bill sticking out from underneath a plate.

As a waiter I make $2.65 an hour. I really do live off your genorosity. I'm stoked because I've been saving up for Battlefield 3.

The waiter then discovered that the $10 bill was no more than 75 percent of the size of a regular $10 bill.

I thought it was a pretty good joke and looked around for an actual tip. Nothing.

All salespeople know that you do NOT want to put a potential customer in a bad mood. So you can imagine how the waiter felt when he turned the fake bill over to read a message "Some things are better than money," followed by a reference to John 3:16.

To put it in secular terms, Jesus didn't make this sale.

This particular tract appears to have been printed by moneytract.com, a site which no longer exists. Presumably moneytract.com didn't intend for its tract to be used in this fashion, but the damage has been done. See The Consumerist and its comments, and see Friendly Atheist and its comments.

And incidentally, Battlefield 3 has a suggested retail price of $59.99. Sounds like a good way for restaurant workers who have been stiffed to take out their aggressions.

And that's all I have to say, except for the postscript. And if you're a friendly atheist (or an unfriendly one), I suggest that you skip the postscript.

OK.

The postscript is coming...

now.

P.S. As I noted in a Google+ thread on the topic:

This is what happens when you do the work of evangelizing without caring about the people you are evangelizing - in which case, the evangelism is empty.

Along these same lines, Christianity Today published comments from several people regarding the effectiveness, or ineffectiveness, of tracts.

Saturday, December 3, 2011

The problems with signing up for a service by e-mail address

There are a number of services that want you to sign up for them. But how should you identify yourself to the service?

There are still a few services that want U.S. citizens to sign up with their Social Security Number. Because of privacy concerns, this is not advisable.

Some services allow you to sign up with your name. However, if your name is John Smith or Pedro Gomez, this may be problematic.

Some services allow you to create a handle. This is a pretty good solution, as long as you remember the handle that you used.

Some services came up with a pretty good idea, on the face of it - sign up with your e-mail address. Your e-mail address is (unless something goes horribly wrong) a unique identifier which you will presumably remember.

But what if your e-mail address changes?

Usually this isn't a problem. Just tell the service what your new e-mail address is, allow the service to verify that the e-mail address actually exists, and then you're good to go.

Sometimes, however, the one field in your profile that you CAN'T edit happens to be your e-mail address.

Why would you want to edit your e-mail address? Let me give you one example. Back in September 2008 I was an employee of Motorola. Then it was announced that our division would be sold, pending government approvals. While awaiting government approvals (in which the sale could be ratified or rejected), we had to identify the entity under a temporary name. After the sale was approved, we were merged into the IT apparatus of the new owner - a process that took some time. Because of this sale and some other events, I have had four work e-mail addresses over the last three years.

You can imagine how much fun it is to go to an account, find out that there is no way to change your e-mail address, and then have to manually request a change to your e-mail address.

Sometimes it's easier to just forget about updating the e-mail address and letting the account lapse.

So why do service providers make it so difficult to change the e-mail address associated with an account? There are a few cases in which the e-mail address is a critical component of the service itself. Yammer is an example here - since Yammer connects you with people based upon a verified corporate e-mail address, I can understand why Yammer doesn't allow me to change my e-mail address willy-nilly.

But in other cases, the restrictions on changing an e-mail address don't make sense at all. Take a certain information service provider that provides me with information every week, whether I want it or not. Even if the people who sign up with this service provider don't go through all of the reorgs that I've been through, the people in this industry - the computing industry - have been known to change jobs from time to time. If qualification for the service was 100% dependent upon the company that employs you, I could understand why it would be hard to change your e-mail address at will. But somehow, I suspect that the service would continue to provide me with information no matter where I was employed.

So if you are a service provider and are wondering why you have so many dead accounts, perhaps it's because you wouldn't allow your subscribers to update their e-mail addresses.

Friday, December 2, 2011

Hesitate - negotiate (passengers vs. airline in Hong Kong)

Just about everything that you encounter has a list of terms and conditions, in which things are printed in black and white. In the proposal world, I encounter a number of terms and conditions from various customers. No, I won't give any examples, but I can say that at the end of the day, just because something is printed on paper does not mean that it will come true.

CNN reports a case in Hong Kong where some airline passengers were due compensation. According to the letter of the contract between each passenger and the airline company, the compensation was supposed to be a certain amount. For the nine-hour flight delay, the compensation was supposed to be $50 (I don't know if that is US$50, or some other denomination).

But some passengers used a clever negotiation tactic:

When Hong Kong Airlines flight 752 from Singapore arrived at 530 a.m. Wednesday morning, the airline says 80 passengers refused to get off. The travelers, mainly members of package tours from mainland China, demanded the airline increase the original compensation offer of $50 per passenger.

Twenty-one of the passengers stayed on board for another five hours, requesting reimbursement for the unused hotel rooms they had paid for the night before. The airport police were called in to negotiate and the passengers finally at 10:25 a.m., after the airline agreed to pay them $150.


The interesting part of this to me? These were passengers from mainland China. Or, to use terms from my youth, "Red China" or "Communist China." Apparently the Cultural Revolution didn't wipe out all traces of a desire for profit-taking.

Thursday, December 1, 2011

Yes, the Department of Motor Vehicles is responsible for car dealerships also

We always think about our Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) as an agency that services (or does not service) drivers within the state. But at least within California, our DMV has additional areas of responsibility, as this press release shows:

DMV Announces Settlement With Chrysler Corp.

Contact: Mike Marando, Armando Botello,
Jan Mendoza, Jaime Garza
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook
www.DMV.ca.gov

Office of Public Affairs
2415 First Avenue
Sacramento, CA 95814
(916) 657-6437
dmvpublicaffairs@dmv.ca.gov

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
November 18, 2011

Automaker will pay state $955,000 for unlawful operation

Sacramento — Chrysler Corp. has agreed to pay $955,000 to the California Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to settle allegations of unlawfully operating a car dealership within the 10-mile market area of independently-owned franchises, the DMV announced today.

In September 2011, the DMV filed an administrative action against Chrysler's occupational licenses and, as part of the administrative settlement, Chrysler agreed to pay the DMV $750,000 in monetary penalties and fines; $160,000 in reimbursements of investigation and legal fees, and up to $45,000 for post-settlement audits.

Background
On May 26, 2011, the New Motor Vehicle Board (NMVB), acting on a petition filed by the California New Car Dealers Association (CNCDA), requested that the DMV investigate whether Chrysler Group LLC committed violations of law in owning La Brea Avenue Motors, Inc. dba La Brea Chrysler Jeep, which was renamed Motor Village LA and relocated to downtown Los Angeles.

The law prohibits a manufacturer from owning a dealership and competing in the sale of vehicles of the same line and make with independently-owned franchisees within a 10-mile relevant market area. There are two major exceptions for manufacturers that own a dealership for less than one year and for situations where there is a reasonable plan to buy out the manufacturer's interest.

In addition to the monetary penalties, fines, and reimbursement, Chrysler has also agreed to sell the Motor Village LA dealership and to a probationary period of three years.

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

Oracle Learning Library - H/T @eddieawad

Eddie Awad is an Oracle ACE Director, which demonstrates that he has a deep technical knowledge of Oracle products.

I cannot write a join statement.

For those with any level of knowledge who want to learn more about Oracle products, Awad has shared a link to the Oracle Learning Library.

If you go to oracle.com/oll, you will be directed to a row of buttons that link to just about every part of Oracle's stack (although I couldn't find hardware). For example, when I clicked on the "Database" button and queried for "Active Data Guard," I received links to six items that told about Active Data Guard. One of these was a 60-minute "Oracle by Example" tutorial.

There are a variety of resources that you can consult to learn how to use Oracle products, and the Oracle Learning Library is a valuable addition to this list.

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

Of course Charles Manson is in his cell. The computer said so.

Bruce Schneier links to an Ars Technica post that reports on a demonstrated ability for a hacker to open a prison cell door from a remote location.

Schneier was stuck by this paragraph in the Ars Technica post:

"You could open every cell door, and the system would be telling the control room they are all closed," Strauchs, a former CIA operations officer, told the [Washington] Times.

(See the Washington Times article here.)

Think of the ramifications of this - not just with prisoners, but with everything. In the prison case, you have a computer screen telling you that Charles Manson is safely in his cell, muttering about George Harrison or whatever Manson does in his cell. But perhaps if you actually went down to the cell, you'd see that he had actually been freed (or, in Strauchs' scenario, killed).

Now extend that to other computerized systems that tell you something that may not be true. I don't believe that we can categorically state that every computer system is 100% accurate. For example, I'm sure that they put some incredible design into traffic lights, but it's probably possible for a situation to arise in which green lights appear in all directions. The possibility may be extremely small, but it's possible.

So if I'm driving down the street and approaching a green light, and I see a car on the other street approaching the intersection without slowing down, it would not be wise for me to say, "Of course he'll stop. He has to have a red light since I have a green light." (Obviously the more likely scenario is that the other driver DOES have a red light, but is ignoring it.)

But what do you do in other cases in which a computer is telling you something that might not be true?

Monday, November 28, 2011

Groupon education of its merchants

While using the Washington Post Social Reader in Facebook, I just read another Groupon problem story entitled "Groupon horror: Bakery must make 102,000 cupcakes." According to the story, Need a Cake Bakery in Woodley (UK) offered a 75% discount on its cupcakes, but didn't cap the maximum number of items available at this price. To meet the demand, Need a Cake Bakery had to hire temporary help at nearly US$20,000 - a move which wiped out the bakery's annual profits.

When stories are offered via the Washington Post Social Reader, you can use your Facebook account to comment on the story. As I read through the comments, one of the biggest topics of discussion was what Groupon should (or should not) have done to educate Need a Cake Bakery before offering its deal. So I got curious - what type of education does Groupon provide for its participating merchants?

I went to Groupon's merchant site at http://www.grouponworks.com/merchant-services. This is different from the main Groupon site - it even has a different micrologo. The merchant services site is definitely targeted toward merchants:

Merchants come first at Groupon.

The people who are searching for Groupon deals may feel differently - but I digress. The page describes Groupon's merchant education; here are some excerpts:

We collaborate with you to structure a deal that delivers on perfomance goals, expectations and service limitations....

We work with you to calculate the optimal number of Groupon customers relative to regular traffic; calculators are customized to address specific dynamics of key industries (eg, restaurant table turn rate, therapists on staff, etc.)...

We offer advice on ways to convert Groupon customers to your own -- from collecting email addresses on-site to ongoing communications to build strong relationships....

We'll monitor your campaign success and do everything we can to deliver satisfaction and recommend deal structure modifications, if necessary, for subsequent features. Over the long-term we intend to develop a partnership that constantly addresses your ever-changing merchant needs.


From the sound of things, Groupon offers merchants the opportunity to educate themselves on how to structure the deal - but once the deal is set, it's set. This is understandable, since anyone who sees a guaranteed deal for a 75% discount on cupcakes would be very displeased if the deal were suddenly withdrawn.

But even with education, does the model work? Amy Lee at the Huffington Post surveyed various sources back in June. According to Ronan Percival (as quoted by Dylan Collins, the beauty salon appointment segment requires a 10% conversion of Groupon buyers into regular clients - however, it appears that the actual conversion rate is only 1%. Back in 2010, the Wall Street Journal referenced a Rice University study, which showed varying performance between merchants:

The Rice study found that 66% of the 150 merchants responding found the program profitable, while 32% said they were unprofitable. Forty percent of the respondents said they would not run such a promotion again.

There was another interesting ramification from the Rice study:

“Satisfied employees” is the most important factor for the Groupon promotion to work successfully for a business, according to the study. If employees remain satisfied through the promotion, the likelihood of its profitability is significantly higher. The percentage of discount offered and the number of Groupons sold did not predict the deal’s profitability, nor did the percentage of Groupon users who purchased beyond the Groupon’s value or purchased again at full price.

“Because the Groupon customer base is made up of deal-seekers and bargain shoppers, they might not tip as well as an average customer or be willing to purchase beyond the deal,” said Utpal Dholakia, author of the study and associate professor of marketing at the Jones School. “So employees need to be prepared for this type of customer and the sheer volume of customers that might come through.”


Interesting observation, because if the employees are dissatisfied - especially in a small company - then the business owner is going to have a big problem. Take a look at this post:

The food lived up to its excellent reputation, but the only way to get our server’s attention was to flail my arms about like some over-eager 2nd grader dying to be called on by the teacher. If anything, service at a four-star restaurant should border on hovering. This felt more as if we were being quarantined for some highly contagious virus .... We couldn’t help but think that our early admission of using the Groupon had an overall negative impact on service.

Why?

The servers I’ve spoken with all complain that users frequently tip on the discounted amount, and not on the actual amount of the food. For expensive restaurants like the one we went to, that could mean the difference of $100 – $200.

Of course, this is not just limited to Groupon. Businesses need to evaluate every advertising method they use - their websites, their banner advertising, their telephone directory listings (remember telephone directories?) - to determine not only the business return on investment, but also the types of customers that will be attracted by the advertising medium.

And of course there is a responsibility for the customer also. The Southern California restaurant chain Don Jose offers a Fiesta Club that provides coupons once a month - sometimes more frequently. The usual coupon entitles the bearer to one free dinner entree with purchase of a second one at equal or higher value (offer good Sunday through Thursday only). My wife and I use these coupons frequently - but when we do, we calculate the tip based upon the pre-discount amount, not the post-discount amount.

Of course, I'm sure the the number of patrons from the Fiesta Club is much lower than the number of patrons who would suddenly show up if a Groupon promotion were run.

Saturday, November 26, 2011

I was wrong - the NBA lockout will probably be settled in 2011

[Live from the Corner Bakery Cafe at the South Coast Plaza in Costa Mesa, California]

When you read some business blogs, there may be bloggers that gloss over strong pronouncements that they had previously made, but that no longer turn out to be true.

As for me, I take perverse delight in ridiculing myself when I am wrong about an issue.

I figured that the NBA owners and players had become so entrenched in their stands that there was no way that the strike would be settled this year. In fact, I was speculating on the possibility that the owners might even consider bringing in replacement players.

Quoting from Jim Bakker, I was wrong.

Reports today indicate that the the owners and player representatives have reached an agreement, and that leaders from both sides will urge ratification. Should this happen, the NBA is hoping to hold its high-profile Christmas games.

Some effort is being devoted to determining who blinked. Some reports indicate that the owners blink, but you have to remember that the players were guaranteed to lose ground no matter what agreement was reached.

An FBI reminder in advance of Cyber Monday

The United States Federal Bureau of Investigation is responsible for investing a variety of Federal crimes, including online crimes. In that spirit, the FBI has released this announcement from Special Agent Herbert Stapleton.

A healthy dose of skepticism will go a long way keeping people protected when shopping only online on cyber Monday - and throughout the year. Abide by the old adage- if it looks too good to be true then it probably is.

Go here to find the link to the podcast. The FBI warns of the following types of scams:

Fraudulent auction sales, gift card scams and phishing e-mails are among the many techniques cyber criminals use to lure their victims.

Yes, blog reading can be very seasonal

I am happy.

My Empoprise-BI business blog has accumulated enough junk valuable material so that people are reaching the blog because of things that I have already written. This ensures that the blog will continue to have a steady readership, rather than just depending upon my latest post.

I checked my analytics for Thursday, November 24 and found that the two most popular posts on that day were these posts:

Both of these oven-related posts were very popular on Thanksgiving Day, when everyone was cooking turkeys in their ovens. Hope that the birds came out OK.

Friday, November 25, 2011

What if the wireless spectrum were not allocated by the government?

OK, for some people it's obvious that Carly Foulkes is not the most important part of the AT&T/T-Mobile story.

In my previous post, you'll recall that I linked to a Google+ thread shared by Eoghann Irving. I reshared this item, and a discussion began on my own thread. Various people weighed in on the ramifications of a possible rejection of the AT&T acquisition, mentioning various scenarios (including a likely rejection of a Google attempt to take over T-Mobile, since Google now owns Motorola Mobility).

Kevin LeCureux then weighed in:

The worst thing for Telecom competition and improvement is the FCC.

To put LeCureux's comment in perspective, let me share a comment that I almost added to the thread, but didn't. My comment, which would have been addressed to Alex Scoble, would have gone something like this:

Alex, even the most doctrinaire libertarian would agree that this is good news for cell provider competition. Unlike oligopoly conditions in some other industries, the cell provider industry depends upon a scarce resource, regulated by the government - namely, the wireless spectrum. Since you can't create any more spectrum, it makes sense that the DOJ and FCC are stepping in here.

Like I said, I was thinking about writing something like this, but didn't. So when Kevin LeCureux stated that the FCC WAS the problem, I was naturally curious. So I asked:

+Kevin LeCureux, do you have a concern with the FCC's stance on the AT&T/T-Mobile merger, or are you talking about another FCC action?

As you can see from the thread, LeCureux had a problem with the idea of the FCC regulating the spectrum in the first place.

So much for my idea that hardly anyone would question the FCC's right to have jurisdiction in the AT&T/T-Mobile matter.

LeCureux promised to provide a link to a post in which this was discussed in more detail, and he did provide the link. While the main issue addressed in LeCureux's August post is rural wireless access, some of his points can be extrapolated to the allocation of all portions of the spectrum, including cellular phone access.

Let me touch on one part of the topic - if there isn't an FCC around to grant portions of the spectrum to individual companies, then how do we prevent companies from stepping on each other in the spectrum? LeCureux specifically addressed that issue:

What about interference? How would it be prevented? In the courts, just like any property rights. The company that is claiming to be interfered against could ask for an injunction against the allegedly interfering party until the matter gets a court date. The plaintiff would have to provide evidence of infringement and damages, just like any other property damage case. Each party would have to provide evidence that they were the first to use that part of the spectrum, for example by showing equipment purchases, electrical bills, independent field measurement surveys, customer invoices, and so forth.

A key part of the proposal outlined by LeCureux is homesteading - if you want a piece of the spectrum, you have to actually use it. If you stop using it, then someone else can step in and use it.

But wouldn't all of the spectrum always be in use, you may ask. Actually, Dave Burstein notes that much of the spectrum that has been allocated today is unused:

Across the vast bulk of the country, T has plenty of spectrum not used at all right now. In a very limited number of places, there's little. Across the country, the figure is probably 20-60%, but that's a wild guess. Upgrade inefficient uses and put the fallow spectrum to use, and T can easily handle five times the current demand and probably ten to twenty times without adding spectrum.

And even where the spectrum is used, it's not necessarily used efficiently. Burstein:

FCC sources tell me there's a massive efficiency improvement possible if more carriers shared spectrum but none were willing. AT&T Wireless & Cingular did a joint build in New York City that saved $100's of millions according to CFO Ron Dykes. AT&T and T-Mobile could do the same and get most of the spectrum advantage of the merger while staying independent.

And if the merger bid is rejected, that might be what AT&T and T-Mobile may have to do - although T-Mobile may not want to do so, since it would reduce the possibility of its being bought out by someone else.

Back to LeCureux's proposal. In a sense, it's a departure from the way things have been done in the past. If I buy up a whole bunch of land but don't use it, I have the perfect right to do so - well, at least until the government uses eminent domain to put a sports stadium or shopping center on my land.

And perhaps the "eminent domain" issue applies here, in a sense. Cellular provider X is sitting on a lot of spectrum but not doing anything with it. A case could be made that this harms the economy. And because of this, government needs to step in...and immediately get out of the way.

I encourage you to read LeCureux's entire proposal - there's a lot that I didn't get into here. Then I ask you to comment at LeCureux's post, or perhaps at this post or elsewhere - whether you're talking about rural wireless Internet or about the cellular phone spectrum, would a "homesteading" type of solution offer better service than the current spectrum auction system?

The 99% are armed also

On Thursday morning, Loren Feldman started a Google+ thread about Black Friday. He's against it.

I shared the following in Feldman's thread:

Black Friday has nothing to do with shopping. It's an EVENT, like the people who wait in line for days for a movie or gadget. Or the people who snare Super Bowl tickets without knowing the difference between a safety and a safety pin.

Needless to say, I wasn't out shopping at 4am or even midnight (no, I didn't go to Kohl's at midnight). When I woke up this morning, I was curious to know if there had ben any tragedies on Black Friday.

Thankfully, as far as I know, no one was killed. But, according to a Mark Krynsky link to a Los Angeles Times article, a shopper at a Wal-Mart in Porter Ranch used pepper spray and injured at least seven people.

Yes, pepper spray.

For the last couple of weeks, pepper spray is all that we've heard about after the incident at UC Davis in which a campus police officer pepper sprayed someone. No, no one was killed by the pepper spray, but because of all of the reaction, you'd think that someone had been. Let's put it this way - Jerry Sandusky is happy because no one's talking about him any more - now they're talking about John Pike, and doctoring up pictures of John Pike, and everything else. Pike has become - A MEME.

Meanwhile, Wal-Mart woman is still on the loose as of last report. And of course no one will blame the woman for the incident; it's all Wal-Mart's fault, of course.

Perhaps the occupiers will demand that all stores close between Thanksgiving and Christmas to eliminate the profit-taking corporate greed. Yeah, that's a solution.

Guess I'd better not quote Revelation on this Blogger blog

Ignore the fact for a moment that Google, the company that hosts this blog, does business in multiple countries. Pretend for the moment that Google just did business in the United States. In such a situation, Google doesn't necessarily have to listen to EU water-hating bureaucrats or Chinese firewallers - Google only has to listen to American legislators.

That in itself is a lot to listen to, inasmuch as Senator Joe Lieberman is apparently reviewing Blogger's Terms of Service, according to Talking Points Memo. This publication "obtained" a letter that Senator Lieberman wrote to Google's Larry Page on November 22. After discussing what Jose Pimentel used the Blogger/Google servers to do, Lieberman then noted:

Blogger’s Content Policy does not expressly ban terrorist content nor does it provide a ‘flag’ feature for such content.

Apparently Senator Lieberman is not aware how Google works - or doesn't work. I can just picture what would happen if Blogger had a "terrorist" flag. Some Glenn Beck supporter would flag an Obama supporter's blog for advocating Kenyan rule of the United States, and the Obama supporter would then flag the Beck supporter's blog for advocating the mass annihilation of poor people.

And what would happen? If Blogger's flagging policies were anything like YouTube's, the blog would be "permanently disabled," and you wouldn't be able to talk to anyone about it.

Now perhaps Lieberman is (understandably) sensitive about this issue because of the Dmitry Dyatlov affair - incidentally, I have no idea whether Dyatlov used Blogger to post his suggestion that Lieberman was "one Jew, who we absolutely must shoot in the face (many times)."

But in the Dyatlov case, you didn't need Wikipedia-editor types to alert the populace - one of Dyatlov's co-workers alerted the police.

And what is a terrorist post? Is it any post that could fall under the definition of treason? In that case, am I a terrorist if I publish a link to Revelation 19:14-15?

On a more serious note, this blog and every other Blogger blog includes the capability to report terms of service violations, including "Hate or violence" posts. So it appears that Senator Lieberman's concern is already covered.

Thursday, November 24, 2011

Slow news day? Not for Carly Foulkes.

Here in the United States it's Thanksgiving, and of course no business news will appear today.

Or will it? Eoghann Irving alerted us to this story that broke right before the Thanksgiving holiday. AT&T, faced with adverse reaction from the U.S. Federal Communications Commission regarding its planned acquisition of T-Mobile, has withdrawn its bid - temporarily, it claims:

AT&T and Deutsche Telekom Continue to Pursue Sale of DT's U.S. Wireless Assets

Companies Withdraw FCC Applications; AT&T Expects to Recognize $4 Billion Charge; Companies Focus on Gaining DOJ Approval
Dallas, Texas, November 24, 2011

On Nov. 22, 2011, the Federal Communications Commission indicated a proposed order was circulating that would designate for hearing the applications of AT&T Inc. and Deutsche Telekom AG For Consent To Assign or Transfer Control of Licenses and Authorizations, WT Docket No. 11-65. On November 23, 2011, AT&T Inc. and Deutsche Telekom AG electronically withdrew without prejudice, as of that date, the pending applications listed in the Public Notice released by the Federal Communications Commission on April 28, 2011 in that proceeding. Associated manual notification of withdrawal filings also are being made.

AT&T Inc. and Deutsche Telekom AG are continuing to pursue the sale of Deutsche Telekom’s U.S. wireless assets to AT&T and are taking this step to facilitate the consideration of all options at the FCC and to focus their continuing efforts on obtaining antitrust clearance for the transaction from the Department of Justice either through the litigation pending before the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, Case No. 1:11-cv-01560 (ESH) or alternate means. As soon as practical, AT&T Inc. and Deutsche Telekom AG intend to seek the necessary FCC approval.

As a result of the FCC’s action, AT&T expects to recognize a pretax accounting charge of $4 billion ($3 billion cash and $1 billion book value of spectrum) in the 4th quarter of 2011 to reflect the potential break up fees due Deutsche Telekom in the event the transaction does not receive regulatory approval.

About AT&T
AT&T Inc. (NYSE:T) is a premier communications holding company and one of the most honored companies in the world. Its subsidiaries and affiliates – AT&T operating companies – are the providers of AT&T services in the United States and around the world. With a powerful array of network resources that includes the nation’s fastest mobile broadband network, AT&T is a leading provider of wireless, Wi-Fi, high speed Internet, voice and cloud-based services. A leader in mobile broadband and emerging 4G capabilities, AT&T also offers the best wireless coverage worldwide of any U.S. carrier, offering the most wireless phones that work in the most countries. It also offers advanced TV services under the AT&T U-verse® and AT&T | DIRECTV brands. The company’s suite of IP-based business communications services is one of the most advanced in the world. In domestic markets, AT&T Advertising Solutions and AT&T Interactive are known for their leadership in local search and advertising.

Additional information about AT&T Inc. and the products and services provided by AT&T subsidiaries and affiliates is available at http://www.att.com. This AT&T news release and other announcements are available at http://www.att.com/newsroom and as part of an RSS feed at www.att.com/rss. Or follow our news on Twitter at @ATT.

Cautionary Language Concerning Forward-Looking Statements
Information set forth in this press release contains financial estimates and other forward-looking statements that are subject to risks and uncertainties, and actual results might differ materially. A discussion of factors that may affect future results is contained in AT&T's filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. AT&T disclaims any obligation to update and revise statements contained in this news release based on new information or otherwise.


The good news? The T-Mobile pitchwoman, Carly Foulkes, apparently will be able to keep her job for a while.

Don't go vanilla on a job application

In honor of Thanksgiving here in the United States, I'll adopt a food theme for this post, although it's not really about food.

I recently participated in an election in which three candidates were running for a position within a particular organization. I won't reveal the position or the organization (although some of my readers may know what I'm talking about), so let's just say that the Widget Guild is seeking a Chocolate Manager.

As I mentioned, there are three candidates for the position. All three candidates have a lot of widget experience, as detailed in their candidate statements.

But only one of them spent any appreciable time talking about chocolate.

One candidate included an extensive resume that talked about widgets in detail. One line in the resume mentioned sweeteners, but didn't explicitly mention chocolate.

A second candidate's resume didn't talk about chocolate at all. But there was a mention of chocolate at the very beginning:

JOHN DOE
CHIEF STRATEGIST
CHOCOLATE MANAGER
JOHN DOE INCORPORATED


The third candidate did devote a long sentence to a discussion of previous chocolate experience.

Now perhaps if I knew these three people, I'd find out that all three of them have a lot of chocolate experience. But I don't know any of them, so I had to rely on their candidate statements to see how they felt about chocolate.

I'm just shocked that two of them hardly talked about chocolate at all. They trotted out generic resumes, but didn't make any effort to customize the resumes to match the position for which they were applying.

Why am I shocked? Let's just say that these, um, "widget" experts should have known better.

Wednesday, November 23, 2011

(empo-tuulwey) @stevedenning on Clayton Christensen, Ratios, and Absolutes

When I was taking my MBA classes at Cal State Fullerton, we spent a lot of time analyzing companies and looking at various ratios.

According to a Forbes article by Steve Denning (H/T Bill Gross via a Google+ share), Clayton Christensen believes that our concentration on these ratios is stifling innovation in the United States.

Christensen cites the story of an American company, Dell, who pursued higher profitability ratios and ended up creating a competitor:

Christensen retells the story of how Dell [DELL] progressively lopped off low-value segments of its PC operation to the Taiwan-based firm ASUSTek [LSE: ASKD]—the motherboard, the assembly of the computer, the management of the supply chain and finally the design of the computer. In each case Dell accepted the proposal because in each case its profitability improved: its costs declined and its revenues stayed the same. At the end of the process, however, Dell was little more than a brand, while ASUSTeK can—and does—now offer a cheaper, better computer to Best Buy at lower cost.

Dell isn't the only company who has outsourced huge chunks of operations to Asia. Morris Chang, whose company TSMC is one of the beneficiaries of American outsourcing, thinks that we're crazy:

You Americans measure profitability by a ratio. There’s a problem with that. No banks accept deposits denominated in ratios. The way we measure profitability is in ‘tons of money’. You use the return on assets ratio if cash is scarce. But if there is actually a lot of cash, then that is causing you to economize on something that is abundant.

Read the rest of the Forbes article here.

In the spirit of what Christensen has said, it's interesting to read the press release which accompanied Dell's latest quarterly statement. Here are some excerpts:

Dell's continued strategic focus on higher-value opportunities, combined with an increased mix of enterprise solutions and services sales, resulted in increased profitability on revenue of $15.4 billion in its third quarter, flat compared with revenue a year ago....

Revenue for Dell's enterprise solutions and services business -- including sales of servers, storage, networking, and services -- increased 8 percent over the same quarter last year to $4.7 billion, an all-time high. As the revenue mix steadily shifts more to the higher-value enterprise portfolio, Dell is delivering on its commitment to improve profitability, with operating income up 12 percent for the quarter and at 7.6 percent of revenue for the fiscal year to date.


So Dell is moving into "higher-value" businesses - something that many people, including myself, would praise. I've been in the software industry for over two decades - sometimes in software-only situations, and sometimes in situations in which fairly unique software is bundled with mostly-commodity hardware. With this mix of hardware and software, software is obviously better from a margin standpoint.

So what has this targeted strategy done for Dell?

Revenue in the quarter was $15.4 billion, flat compared with the same quarter last year.

Remember what Morris Chang said. From Chang's perspective, are this year's dollars better than last year's dollars? And when you look at Dell division by division, you can see some cracks in the story.

Consumer revenue was $2.8 billion, a 6 percent decline. Operating income was $76 million or 2.7 percent of revenue. The migration to higher-value products has proven to be effective, with overall company revenue for the high-end XPS consumer laptop growing 207 percent. XPS revenue now accounts for nearly 20 percent of Dell's total consumer laptop business.

An outstanding success story - and it's probably the reason why I'm not typing this post on a Dell (or Hewlett-Packard) computer. In fact, I happen to be using an Asus netbook.

Of course, we all know that schlock companies like Asus are no competition for a strong American company like Dell.

And of course, thirty years ago we all knew that schlock companies like Dell and Compaq (at the moment, part of Hewlett-Packard) were no competition for a strong American computer manufacturer like IBM.

Tuesday, November 22, 2011

(empo-tymshft) Raining on the cloud

I have said before that IT philosophy swings like a pendulum between centralized and decentralized models. Time-sharing gave way to individual PCs, and then we centralized, and then we de-centralized. This week's buzzword is "the cloud," which leans toward the centralized end of things again. Whether you're talking about enterprise stuff, or you're talking about consumer stuff, the cloud offers you the wonderful capability to store things in a central location and access them from anywhere. Everyone involved in IT, with the possible exception of Ashton Kutcher, has been bombarded with cloud sales pitches.

But the praise of the cloud is not unanimous. Peter Evans-Greenwood argues that the cloud is outdated.

...the future of IT in business will be determined by the need to knit together a fabric of IT enabled services, many of which will be obtained externally. I don’t need a project portfolio management solution, I need a portfolio management capability backed by the tools and skills required to make it work. I don’t need a CRM solution (SaaS or not), I need a sales management and reporting methodology (Holden? Miller Heiman?) supported by technology to enable it to scale. It’s outside in thinking, rather than inside out.

What will the industry that accretes around this new need look like? If we look at many of the current on-demand / SaaS vendors, then they could best be described as enterprise software, but in the cloud!. Take the old model and make it multi-tennanted.


However, I don't see such a market happening - because of organizational behavior. In such a "cloud 2.0" market, you'd have all of these different services vendors who plug and play with other stuff. However, no vendor is willing to do just one thing. Remember when Oracle was a database company? Now they offer everything from hardware to vertical software packages. Why? Because Oracle belives it can make more money by offering a bigger share of the pie. If you go tell Larry Ellison to divest most of Oracle, and concentrate on making the best possible database that will be interoperable with everything else, Ellison (and Ellison's stockholders) will tell you to go pound sand.

So don't expect objects - whoops, that's an old term - to dominate the market any time soon.

Monday, November 21, 2011

Note to Kohl's - you want people to LIKE your Black Friday commercials

There's a reason why I'm posting this in my business blog rather than my music blog. But first, let me tell you what I'm posting about.

The song "Friday" by Rebecca Black.

I've never written a full-fledged post about the song, either here or in my music blog (although this post linked to a Google+ discussion of the song), but most everyone knows the story. In case you don't - young girl and her parents contract with some El-Lay people to create a song and video to show off the girl's talents. The El-Lay people come up with a song late one night, and the lyrics are (to put it mildly) not all that good, even for pop music. The song is then recorded, but the girl's voice is smothered in auto-tune and stuff by the El-Lay people. The video shoot looked like it was kind of fun. The video was posted on YouTube, and then it went viral.

Why? Because, according to the ears of (literally) millions, the song was REALLY BAD.

The girl got a lot of attention that she really didn't want to get, and is now trying to restart her career, but not with the El-Lay people that she worked with previously.

Meanwhile, the song has garnered a reputation on a standing with other failures, such as "Heaven's Gate" and the Los Angeles Clippers - things that cause a negative reaction when you hear about them (or, in the case of the song "Friday," hear it).

Normal businesses would run away from such failures.

But the advertising agency that does commercials for Kohl's instead chose to embrace this failure.



The advertisers, thinking that the song was catchy, added this comment to the posting of the video:

You'll be singing this song every day until Black Friday. Guaranteed.

I guess the people at the advertising agency thought they had picked a winner. This was a song that everyone was talking about! And it includes the word "Friday" prominently in the song! And our sale will take place on Friday!

What could go wrong?

Apparently the advertisers didn't consider WHY the song was so famous. And I'm sure that some advertiser is looking at the YouTube votes and wondering, "Hey, why does our video have 646 likes and 1,191 dislikes?"

Now I didn't influence that voting - since YouTube permanently disabled my account, I can't vote.

But unless you're marketing to specific audiences, you want your customers to feel good about what you're advertising. Based upon the numerous negative reactions on YouTube and on other places such as Google! and Gizmodo, people aren't feeling good about Kohl's right now.

Can airport X-ray scanners break electronic ink Kindles? It's uncertain.

Shawn Rossi shared something that led me to a widely-read Telegraph article entitled "Amazon Kindles 'damaged by airport scanners.'" Christopher Williams quotes some anecdotal evidence, and then quotes a statement from Professor Daping Chu of the University of Cambridge. Professor Chu said, in part:

[Y]ou can get a build up of static inside these machines, caused by the rubber belt rubbing. If that charge were to pass through a Kindle, it’s conceivable that it could damage the screen.

Apparently this only affects "electronic ink" screens, and doesn't affect the LCD screens used by other devices. But Amazon says that it doesn't happen at all (although the Telegraph notes that Amazon has replaced some devices):

Exposing your Kindle to an X-ray machine, such as those used by airport security, should not cause and problems with it.

This is not a new issue - I found a May 2009 report of a similar issue. Incidentally, the fact that an Amazon customer service rep stated in 2009 that X-rays could be a cause of the failure doesn't mean much to me - individual reps can say all sorts of things.

The problems with transparency

There are those that say that consumers are better served when companies are transparent. As a result, "transparency" has become a rallying cry for consumer watchdogs and boardroom activists and the famed "social media experts." (My view: if you call yourself a "social media expert," you probably aren't. My other view: if you work the acronym "SEO" into your content, I probably won't read it. But I digress.)

Years ago, I was talking with two different people at a then-competitor of my then-employer. I asked them both why they didn't print a customer list on their company's web page. One person believed that this should happen. The other disagreed, saying that the only people who would pay attention to such a list would be competitors such as myself.

I was reminded of this when I read something that Jason Alba recently wrote about company pages on LinkedIn:

The advocates are suggesting that people will come to your Company page, learn about your company, and then buy something (or something like that).

Everyone else teaches LinkedIn users how to use Companies to do competitive intelligence research, figure out how to network into a company, sell something to that company, or even steal employees from that company (recruiters would do this).


Go here to read Alba's advice about company pages (although you can probably guess what he advises).